Sandals vs Secrets Resorts: Which All-Inclusive Is Better for Couples in 2026?

Sandals resorts are the better choice for couples who want a premium Caribbean-only experience with unlimited scuba diving and no kids on property, while Secrets resorts offer a wider range of destinations at a slightly lower price point. I have personally visited all 17 Sandals properties and several Secrets resorts throughout Mexico and the Caribbean, so here is my honest comparison based on first-hand experience.

Choosing between Sandals and Secrets is one of the most common questions I get from couples planning an all-inclusive vacation. Both are adults-only brands with strong reputations, but they cater to very different types of travelers. Let me break down exactly where each brand excels.

---

Quick Comparison: Sandals vs Secrets

---

Where Sandals Wins

All-Inclusive Value

Sandals includes more in the base price than any other all-inclusive brand. Scuba diving alone would cost $100-$200 per day at a Secrets resort. Add in airport transfers ($50-$100 per couple each way), premium brand liquor (not just well drinks), and water sports like water skiing and tubing, and the Sandals “premium” disappears quickly.

Couples-Only Focus

Sandals properties are exclusively for couples, not just adults-only. This means the entire resort experience is designed around romantic getaways. Secrets allows any adults 18+, which can include bachelor/bachelorette parties, friend groups, and solo travelers.

Caribbean Authenticity

If your goal is an authentic Caribbean vacation, Sandals delivers. The resorts are owned and operated in the Caribbean, employ local staff, and showcase Caribbean culture, food, and music. Most Secrets properties are in Mexico’s Riviera Maya or Cancun hotel zones.

Butler and Club Level Service

Sandals’ butler service is genuinely exceptional. Your butler handles restaurant reservations, in-room dining, beach setup, excursion booking, and personal requests. Secrets’ “Preferred Club” is a step up from standard but does not offer the same level of personalized attention.

---

Where Secrets Wins

Price Point

For budget-conscious couples, Secrets typically offers lower nightly rates, especially at their Mexico and Dominican Republic properties. You can find Secrets rooms starting around $200/person/night, while the cheapest Sandals starts around $250.

Mexico and Beyond

If you want to visit Mexico, Costa Rica, or Spain, Secrets has options that Sandals simply does not. The Riviera Maya and Cancun locations are popular for good reason, with easy flights from most U.S. cities and exceptional Mayan ruin day trips.

Swim-Out Suites

Secrets popularized the swim-out suite concept in the all-inclusive space. If walking directly from your room into a semi-private pool is a priority, Secrets has more options at more price points.

Spa Integration

Secrets resorts often integrate their spa experience more centrally into the resort design, with some properties offering hydrotherapy circuits included in the room rate for Preferred Club guests.

---

My Recommendation

For a honeymoon, anniversary, or special romantic occasion, I recommend Sandals over Secrets every time. The couples-only atmosphere, included scuba and water sports, and butler service options create a premium experience that Secrets does not match. If you are planning a casual getaway on a tighter budget and Mexico is appealing, Secrets is a solid choice.

The biggest mistake I see couples make is comparing the base nightly rate without factoring in what is included. A $300/night Sandals stay often delivers more total value than a $250/night Secrets stay once you add scuba, transfers, and premium drink options.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

---

Steve Griswold is a Sandals CRC Platinum Elite Advisor with 15+ years of Caribbean travel experience. For a personalized resort recommendation, visit PixieVacations.com.